How
To Handle A Critique
You Were Supposed To Say How Wonderful I Am!
© 1999 Angela Walsh
Okay, here's the scenario:
You wake up one morning with inspiration that must have
come from the Lord above! You rush around, frantically searching
for a pen that works and something-- ANYTHING-- to write
on. Hurry!!! You can't lose these thoughts!
In
a maniacal frenzy of ink and scribbles, you finally end
this masterpiece. Once you catch your breath, you read it
and realize that you are the world's new lyrical genius.
So, after correcting a few mistakes (after all, you're not
a PERFECT genius!), you decide to share your brilliance
with others. This is when your ego is deflated!
First of all, it's a difficult step to go from writing to
sharing your work with others. You become extremely vulnerable.
As artists, we are naturally sensitive. In most cases, we
are more sensitive than the average person. Our work is
a part of us, and more often than not, it is derived from
personal experiences.
I remember my first critique. I thought I knew it all. A
publisher returned material and had made a few suggestions.
I was instantly hurt and angry. Didn't he feel the way I
did? Couldn't he understand the emotions and statements
that I was making? Looking back at it, I can now see my
mistakes. However, eight years later, it is still difficult
to accept an undesirable critique.
Here are some tips that I have had to use:
1) When
you first read a critique, don't make any judgments. Read
it and then step away. The amount of "away time" depends
on you and the harshness of the critique.
2) Remember
that all critiques are made by humans. We are all different
and our ideas do not always agree with someone else's.
3) Try
to see the other person's point of view. They may actually
have valid points! I know, it is a big step to look at your
work objectively, but YOU CAN DO IT!
4) Keep
a sense of humor at all times. Sometimes we do tend to take
the whole business way too seriously. Don't forget what
brought you here to begin with. Have fun with it.
5) Have
confidence in yourself. If you love a verse that the majority
of critics dislike, trust your gut. After all, it IS your
song. You don't have to change anything if you don't want
to. Stay true to your style. However, once again, try to
see if their points are valid.
6) Be
nice! There are times when you want to say harsh words when
someone gives you a tacky critique. It is best to just ignore
it. Unfortunately, there are those who want nothing more
then to totally bash another person's work. Don't play their
game!
7) Realize
that you are not perfect. You will always need to work on
some part of your writing. Take baby steps and get better
every day.
8) Critique
someone else's work. Try it and you'll see what I mean.
There are a lot songwriting message boards out there. They
have helped me grow as a writer and given me some wonderful
contacts.
9) Last,
say Thank You! Yes, it can be difficult. But, someone took
time out of their life to critique your work. Even if you
don't agree with them, you need to appreciate their effort.
I hope this has helped you. I have enjoyed reading your
e-mail from my other article. Please let me know if you
have any other suggestions.
Have fun and keep on writing,
Angela Walsh
angela@lunarfx.com
angela-walsh@usa.net
|